Comparison of three methods for inorganic carbon in coastal soil from northern Jiangsu

LU Weiwei, HU Jiaxin, CHEN Sihua, CHEN Weiling, FENG Siyu

JOURNAL OF NANJING FORESTRY UNIVERSITY ›› 2023, Vol. 47 ›› Issue (1) : 76-82.

PDF(1311 KB)
PDF(1311 KB)
JOURNAL OF NANJING FORESTRY UNIVERSITY ›› 2023, Vol. 47 ›› Issue (1) : 76-82. DOI: 10.12302/j.issn.1000-2006.202111010

Comparison of three methods for inorganic carbon in coastal soil from northern Jiangsu

Author information +
History +

Abstract

【Objective】 Inorganic carbon constitutes a large proportion of soil carbon storage in the coastal area of northern Jiangsu; therefore, estimating the soil inorganic carbon (SIC) content with precision and accuracy is a prerequisite for further study.【Method】Soil samples at different depths (i.e., 0-10, ≥10-20, ≥20-40, ≥40-60, ≥60-80, and ≥80-100 cm) were collected from a poplor plantation and a Spartina alterniflora wetland. The SIC content as well as its recovery rate were then estimated using a calcimeter, carbon dioxide (CO2) absorption and indirect methods, respectively. This was done to compare the precision and accuracy of the three methods. 【Result】 The ranges of the SIC content estimated by the calcimeter, CO2 absorption and indirect methods were 4.25-9.93, 6.18-11.50 and 5.50-12.60 g/kg with the average of 8.11, 9.58 and 9.54 g/kg, respectively. When the amendment rate of exogenous calcium carbonate was 2.35-12.90 g/kg, the averaged recovery rates of SIC content estimated by the calcimeter, CO2 absorption and indirect methods were 96.9%, 105.0% and 71.5%, respectively. According to the SIC content corrected by the recovery, the SIC contents measured by the indirect method were significantly higher than those measured by the other two methods, indicating that the recovery of SIC measured by the indirect method was underestimated. The coefficients of variation of the SIC content in the parallel soil samples estimated by the calcimeter, CO2 absorption and indirect methods were 1.19%-4.99%, 0.52%-3.34% and 1.51%-6.79% with averages of 2.44, 1.36 and 3.25 g/kg, respectively. 【Conclusion】 The calcimeter, CO2 absorption and indirect methods can all be used to determine the SIC content of coastal soils from Northern Jiangsu, although the SIC estimated by the CO2 absorption and indirect methods were both higher than those measured by the calcimeter method. However, the SIC recovery rate estimated by the indirect method was underestimated, and this was mainly due to the overestimation of the organic carbon content of the acid-treated soils by the potassium dichromate oxidation method. The accuracy of the CO2 absorption method was the highest, followed by that of the calcimeter and indirect methods. However, the calcimeter method is time-saving, whereas the indirect method can quantify the contents of soil organic carbon and SIC simultaneously. In the future, researchers should choose a method that is in line with their specific research purposes.

Key words

inorganic carbon / calcimeter method / CO2 absorption method / indirect method / coastal soil / Spartina alterniflora salt marsh / potassium dichromate oxidation

Cite this article

Download Citations
LU Weiwei , HU Jiaxin , CHEN Sihua , et al . Comparison of three methods for inorganic carbon in coastal soil from northern Jiangsu[J]. JOURNAL OF NANJING FORESTRY UNIVERSITY. 2023, 47(1): 76-82 https://doi.org/10.12302/j.issn.1000-2006.202111010

References

[1]
卢伟伟, 耿慧丽, 张伊蕊, 等. 生物质炭对杨树人工林土壤微生物群落的影响[J]. 南京林业大学学报(自然科学版), 2020, 44(4):143-150.
LU W W, GENG H L, ZHANG Y R, et al. Effects of biochars pyrolyzed at different temperatures on soil microbial community in a poplar plantation in coastal eastern China[J]. J Nanjing For Univ(Nat Sci Ed), 2020, 44(4): 143-150. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1000-2006.201911014.
[2]
LI Z P, HAN F X, SU Y, et al. Assessment of soil organic and carbonate carbon storage in China[J]. Geoderma, 2007, 138(1/2): 119-126. DOI: 10.1016/j.geoderma.2006.11.007.
[3]
ZOUGAGH M, RIOS A, VALCÁRCEL M. Direct determination of total carbonate salts in soil samples by continuous-flow piezoelectric detection[J]. Talanta, 2005, 65(1): 29-35. DOI: 10.1016/j.talanta.2004.05.010.
Two new methods for the determination of total carbonate salts, as CaCO(3), in soil by continuous-flow piezoelectric (PZ) detection are proposed. Both use a piezoelectric flow cell and a manifold including a dynamic gas extraction device to purge gaseous CO(2) released by the sample solution upon acidification. One of the methods involves monitoring the pressure generated by the CO(2) produced upon addition of hydrochloric acid; in the other, the CO(2) is quantified by using a quartz crystal coated with tetramethylammonium fluoride tetrahydrate (TMAF). The precision of both methods is compared with that of the officially endorsed method. The proposed methods allow calcium carbonate amounts over the ranges 10-100mg and 2-15mg, respectively, to be determined. Both were applied to the determination of CaCO(3) in soil samples. The standard deviation and throughput achieved were 2.7% and 30 samples per hour, respectively, with the pressure-based method; and 6.0% and six samples per hour, respectively, with the mass-based method.
[4]
SHERROD L A, DUNN G, PETERSON G A, et al. Inorganic carbon analysis by modified pressure-calcimeter method[J]. Soil Sci Soc Am J, 2002, 66(1): 299-305. DOI: 10.2136/sssaj2002.2990.
[5]
WANG Q R, LI Y C, WANG Y. Optimizing the weight loss-on ignition methodology to quantify organic and carbonate carbon of sediments from diverse sources[J]. Environ Monit Assess, 2011, 174(1/2/3/4): 241-257. DOI: 10.1007/s10661-010-1454-z.
[6]
韩文娟. 新疆天山北坡典型草地土壤无机碳特征[D]. 乌鲁木齐: 新疆农业大学, 2015.
HAN W J. Soil inorganic carbon distribution characteristics in typical grassland in north slope of Tianshan Mountains of Xinjiang[D]. Urumqi: Xinjiang Agricultural University, 2015. DOI: 10.7666/d.Y2886733.
[7]
王莲莲, 杨学云, 杨文静. 土壤碳酸盐几种测定方法的比较[J]. 西北农业学报, 2013, 22(5): 144-150.
WANG L L, YANG X Y, YANG W J. Comparison of three methods for determination of soil carbonate[J]. Acta Agric Boreali Occidentalis Sin, 2013, 22(5): 144-150. DOI: 10.7606/j.issn.1004-1389.2013.05.024.
[8]
陈宗定, 许春雪, 安子怡, 等. 土壤碳赋存形态及分析方法研究进展[J]. 岩矿测试, 2019, 38(2): 233-244.
CHEN Z D, XU C X, AN Z Y, et al. Research progress on fraction and analysis methods of soil carbon[J]. Rock Miner Anal, 2019, 38(2): 233-244. DOI: 10.15898/j.cnki.11-2131/td.201709270148.
[9]
WANG X J, WANG J P, ZHANG J. Comparisons of three methods for organic and inorganic carbon in calcareous soils of northwestern China[J]. PLoS One, 2012, 7(8): e44334. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0044334.
[10]
LEOGRANDE R, VITTI C, CASTELLINI M, et al. Comparison of two methods for total inorganic carbon estimation in three soil types in Mediterranean area[J]. Land, 2021, 10(4): 409. DOI: 10.3390/land10040409.
[11]
许梦璐, 吴炜, 颜铮明, 等. 滨海滩涂不同土地利用类型土壤活性有机碳含量与垂直分布[J]. 南京林业大学学报(自然科学版), 2020, 44(4):167-175.
XU M L, WU W, YAN Z M, et al. Content and vertical distribution of soil labile organic carbons in different land use types in the tidal flat area[J]. J Nanjing For Univ(Nat Sci Ed), 2020, 44(4): 167-175. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1000-2006.202001021.
[12]
YANG P P, SHU Q, LIU Q, et al. Distribution and factors influencing organic and inorganic carbon in surface sediments of tidal Flats in northern Jiangsu, China[J]. Ecol Indic, 2021, 126(1-3): 107633. DOI: 10.1016/j.ecolind.2021.107633.
[13]
YANG R M, YANG F. Impacts of Spartina alterniflora invasion on soil inorganic carbon in coastal wetlands in China[J]. Soil Sci Soc Am J, 2020, 84(3): 844-855. DOI: 10.1002/saj2.20073.
[14]
缪雄谊. 黄河三角洲滨海湿地表层土壤矿物与地球化学特征研究[D]. 青岛: 中国海洋大学, 2014.
MIAO X Y. The geochemical and mineral research of surface soil of coastal wetland in Yellow River Delta[D]. Qingdao: Ocean University of China, 2014.
[15]
洪长桥, 郑光辉, 陈昌春. 苏北滨海土壤碳酸钙含量反射光谱估算研究[J]. 土壤学报, 2016, 53(5): 1120-1129.
HONG C Q, ZHENG G H, CHEN C C. Estimation of CaCO3 content in coastal soil of north Jiangsu with reflectance spectroscopy[J]. Acta Pedol Sin, 2016, 53(5): 1120-1129. DOI: 10.11766/trxb201602250646.
[16]
KASSIM J K. Method for estimation of calcium carbonate in soils from Iraq[J]. Int J Environ, 2013, 1(1): 9-19. DOI: 10.3126/ije.v1i1.8524.
[17]
阳亚平, 马雪洋, 王林, 等. 湖泊沉积物碳酸盐含量3种测定方法的比较[J]. 湖泊科学, 2016, 28(4): 917-924.
YANG Y P, MA X Y, WANG L, et al. Evaluation of three methods used in carbonate content determination for lacustrine sediments[J]. J Lake Sci, 2016, 28(4): 917-924. DOI: 10.18307/2016. 0426.
[18]
VITTI C, STELLACCI A M, LEOGRANDE R, et al. Assessment of organic carbon in soils: a comparison between the Springer-Klee wet digestion and the dry combustion methods in Mediterranean soils (southern Italy)[J]. CATENA, 2016, 137:113-119. DOI: 10.1016/j.catena.2015.09.001.
[19]
唐淑英, 祝寿泉, 单光宗, 等. 苏北滨海盐渍土的形成和演化[J]. 土壤学报, 1978, 15(2): 151-164.
TANG S Y, CHU S C, SHAN K T, et al. The formation and evolution of salt-affected soils in the coastal area of northern Jiangsu[J]. Acta Pedol Sin, 1978, 15(2): 151-164.
[20]
STANTURF J A, VAN OOSTEN C V. Operational poplar and willow culture[M]//Poplars and willows:trees for society and the environment. Wallingford: CABI, 2014: 200-257. DOI: 10.1079/9781780641089.0200.
[21]
沈永明. 江苏沿海互花米草盐沼湿地的经济、生态功能[J]. 生态经济, 2001, 17(9): 72-73, 86.
SHEN Y M. The study of the function of the wetlands of Spartina alternifloura manpower salt mash in Jiangsu[J]. Ecol Econ, 2001, 17(9): 72-73, 86. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1671-4407.2001.09.024.
[22]
鲍士旦. 土壤农化分析[M]. 3版. 北京:中国农业出版社, 2000.
BAO S D. Soil and Agricultural Chemistry Analysis[M]. 3rd ed. Beijing: China Agriculture Press, 2000.
[23]
BUNDY L G, BREMNER J M. A simple titrimetric method for determination of inorganic carbon in soils[J]. Soil Sci Soc Am J, 1972, 36(2): 273-275. DOI: 10.2136/sssaj1972.03615995003600020021x.
[24]
中国林业科学研究院林业研究所.森林土壤有机质的测定及碳氮比的计算: LY/T 1237-1999[S]. 北京: 中国林业科学研究院,1999.
Forestry Institute, CAF. Determination of organic matter in forest soil and calculation carbon-nitrogen ratio: LY/T 1237—1999[S]. Beijing: Chinese Academy of Forestry,1999.
[25]
APESTEGUIA M, PLANTE A F, VIRTO I. Methods assessment for organic and inorganic carbon quantification in calcareous soils of the Mediterranean region[J]. Geoderma Reg, 2018, 12: 39-48. DOI: 10.1016/j.geodrs.2017.12.001.
[26]
彭洪翠, 肖和艾, 吴金水, 等. 土壤碳酸盐间接测定方法研究及其应用[J]. 土壤, 2006, 38(4): 477-482.
PENG H C, XIAO H A, WU J S, et al. An indirect method for determination of soil total carbonate[J]. Soils, 2006, 38(4): 477-482. DOI: 10.3321/j.issn:0253-9829.2006.04.021.
[27]
LING C, LIU Z F, ZHANG J W, et al. Pitfalls of acid leaching method for determining organic and inorganic carbon contents in marine sediments[J]. Acta Oceanol Sin, 2020, 39(8): 96-102. DOI: 10.1007/s13131-020-1631-z.
[28]
DREIMANIS A. Quantitative gasometric determination of calcite and dolomite by using Chittick apparatus[J]. J SEPM J Sediment Res, 1962, 32(3):520-529. DOI: 10.1306/74d70d08-2b21-11d7-8648000102c1865d.
[29]
HORVÁTH B, OPARA-NADI O, BEESE F. A simple method for measuring the carbonate content of soils[J]. Soil Sci Soc Am J, 2005, 69(4): 1066-1068. DOI: 10.2136/sssaj2004.0010.
[30]
VUONG T X, HEITKAMP F, JUNGKUNST H F, et al. Simultaneous measurement of soil organic and inorganic carbon: evaluation of a thermal gradient analysis[J]. J Soils Sediments, 2013(7), 13: 1133-1140. DOI: 10.1007/s11368-013-0715-1.
[31]
BISUTTI I, HILKE I, SCHUMACHER J, et al. A novel single-run dual temperature combustion (SRDTC) method for the determination of organic, inorganic and total carbon in soil samples[J]. Talanta, 2007, 71(2): 521-528. DOI: 10.1016/j.talanta.2006.04.022.
[32]
辜忠春, 李光荣, 杜业云, 等. 外加热重铬酸钾氧化-容量法测定森林土壤有机质影响因素探讨[J]. 湖北林业科技, 2014, 43(2): 24-26.
GU Z C, LI G R, DU Y Y, et al. Investigation on parameters affecting the determination of organic matter in forest soil by potassium dichromate heating oxidation-volumetric method[J]. Hubei For Sci Technol, 2014, 43(2): 24-26. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1004-3020.2014.02.007.
[33]
FONNESBECK B B, BOETTINGER J L, LAWLEY J R. Improving a simple pressure-calcimeter method for inorganic carbon analysis[J]. Soil Sci Soc Am J, 2013, 77(5): 1553-1562. DOI: 10.2136/sssaj2012.0381.
[34]
WALTHERT L, GRAF U, KAMMER A, et al. Determination of organic and inorganic carbon, δ13C, and nitrogen in soils containing carbonates after acid fumigation with HCl[J]. J Plant Nutr Soil Sci, 2010, 173(2): 207-216. DOI: 10.1002/jpln.200900158.
PDF(1311 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended
The full text is translated into English by AI, aiming to facilitate reading and comprehension. The core content is subject to the explanation in Chinese.

/